The audience ABC turns agents, bots, and consumers into product decisions
Product & Tech Initiative Blog | 11 November 2026
In my first post on news companies’ three audiences, I introduced the audience ABC: agents, bots, and consumers (a phrase coined by Madhav Chinappa). After a week in Silicon Valley, I’m clearer about what serving each requires — and how easily a decision about one can affect the others.
The next step is to turn that framework into product decisions: who gets access, what they can do, how value is exchanged, and what experience the person at the end receives.
These categories overlap. A consumer can send an agent that accesses our journalism through automated requests. Treating all that activity in the same way risks blocking a valuable customer or allowing uses we never intended.
A is for agents: Meet the demand that already exists
This is happening now. Dots, Muse, and Instinct are already part of people’s lives.
Consumers are using agents to find, filter, explain, and organise information, even if they don’t call them “agents.” News organisations need to meet that demand or risk losing the connection with the person behind the request.
Start with a paying subscriber who wants their agent to use journalism they already have access to. Establish how the agent proves whom it represents, which subscription permissions apply, and what uses are permitted. Reading on someone’s behalf, redistributing an article, and collecting material for training need separate boundaries.
Make the journalism usable through structured information that preserves its source, date, attribution, and context. Then test the whole experience: Can the subscriber get what they need, and does your brand remain visible and valuable? Build a legitimate route for this behaviour now.
Making readers choose between your subscription and the experience they prefer gives them a reason to leave.
B is for bots: Block by default, whitelist those that deliver value
Not all bots are bad. But there are plenty of bad bots out there, and trying to blacklist each one leaves news organisations constantly playing catch-up.
The stronger approach is to block by default and whitelist the good bots. Restricting unauthorised access also helps starve the black market of professional journalism and strengthen demand for legitimate access.
Be clear about what makes each one valuable: Does it support discovery, deliver audience, enable advertising, serve paying subscribers, or generate licensing revenue?
Know what each bot gives you in exchange for access to your journalism. Verify who operates it, set permissions for what it can access and do, and monitor whether its behaviour matches the agreement. Product, commercial, and security teams need to make these decisions together, including identifying the legitimate services your business depends on.
Review the value exchange regularly. Access should be a deliberate business decision, with a clear benefit you can assess.

C is for consumers: Give people more control over the experience
Test the journey of someone who values your journalism but wants to consume it elsewhere.
Can they use their subscription through their preferred tools? Can they get a short briefing, ask for an explanation, or move into the full reporting without repeatedly proving they have paid? Research the friction before assuming the answer is another feature inside your app.
Build around needs such as catching up, understanding an unfamiliar issue, and knowing when someone has read enough. Let readers express preferences and correct the experience while retaining editorial judgment about what deserves their attention. Personal context should help journalism become more relevant and understandable, with clear choices about what information people share.
Alongside this, keep investing in direct relationships: recognisable journalists, useful products, events, and communities that give people a reason to belong. Letting journalism travel should strengthen the relationship with your news organisation.
Measure success through usefulness, satisfaction, retention, and willingness to pay, alongside visits and time spent. A reader getting value through an agent may remain a strong customer even as their website behaviour changes.
The practical next step is to bring these decisions together. Choose one subscriber journey and follow it from the person’s request through authentication, content access, presentation, and payment. Identify where responsibility sits and where the experience breaks.
That exercise will expose the tension we need to resolve: protecting journalism’s value while making it easier for people to benefit from it. Our audience strategy now needs to do both. Every media executive should at least try a personal agent to understand first-hand what the next generation of consumer products — including news—could look like.
If you’d like to subscribe to my bi-weekly newsletter, INMA members can do so here.








